Five years later, calls for accountability over fall of Mosul continue

On the fifth anniversary of the fall of Mosul, people decry that no one has been held accountable for the tragedy.

al-monitor Islamic State fighters celebrate on vehicles taken from Iraqi security forces, Mosul, Iraq, June 12, 2014.  Photo by REUTERS.

Jun 13, 2019

With much of it still in ruins amid struggles to restore its basic infrastructure, Mosul is marking the fifth anniversary of its dramatic fall to the Islamic State.

On June 11, Ayad Allawi, the head of Wataniya Alliance, called for a full investigation of the June 2014 fall of Mosul.

The Sadrist Sairoon bloc also called on the Iraqi parliament to reopen the file involving Mosul's collapse.

"Five years have passed since the fall of Mosul, and its wounds are still felt by Iraqis’ conscience and memory," said Hamdallah al-Rikabi, a spokesman for the bloc. "The consequences of that disaster are still visible. The people are still displaced and the infrastructure is destroyed, while people are suffering the loss of parents and beloved ones, whether they are martyrs or missing persons."

He said, “Remembering that painful day alone is not enough.” He added, “We must bring that file to the forefront, especially with the presence of a report from the parliament’s Committee on Security and Defense that had come to important conclusions after an in-depth study and investigation of the causes of the fall of Mosul.” 

Rikabi spoke of the importance of revealing the facts through trying those believed responsible, even though he said he had doubts about the government's ability to hold such trials because the perpetrators still have influence in the state.

In late March, the bloc previously asked the parliament to reopen the file of the fall of Mosul when Sairoon spokesman Hassan al-Aquli accused influential officials of being behind the collapse of the city. He said “Iraq’s biggest file of corruption” had drained the country’s financial and human resources in addition to causing the destruction of entire cities.

Rikabi’s call to bring the perpetrators of the Mosul to justice, facilitate the return of displaced persons, compensate the victims and reconstruct the areas affected by the destruction and devastation echo the calls of Mosul residents themselves.

For those who live in Ninevah province, what happened is an experience that continues to be lived daily rather than a past memory.

While Yvonne Edward is a clinical psychologist helping others overcome war traumas, she still feels the negative aspects of displacement and war herself.

“The last five years were so harsh,” said Edward, now in Alqosh, a Christian town in the Ninevah Plains that survived Islamic State (IS) occupation in 2014. “I still remember the nightmares, the uncertainty of quitting my university exams in Mosul, the displacement and the emigration of many of my family members.”

For Edward, her patients and many citizens, what happened in 2014 is now exacerbated by the general feeling that no one is being held accountable.

Mahmoud Ezzo, a political scientist at Mosul University, said that when IS took over Mosul, he felt abandoned by the state for the first time in his life. “I felt that Iraq was not able to protect its citizens,” Ezzo told Al-Monitor, “For me, the state should be able to secure our lives and future rather than providing us with a monthly salary only.”

The future of Mosul is still uncertain for Ezzo, who feels disappointed that those who allowed IS to take over Mosul are not being held accountable.

“When a political bloc reopens the file on the fall of Mosul, this means the bloc has the intention to settle its accounts with its political rivals through this action,” Ezzo said, “The parties that contributed directly and indirectly in the fall of Mosul can easily be identified, starting with the misleading information provided by the military leaders to their supreme leadership, the collaborators with IS who were praising its actions under the name of resistance and jihad, to the advocates of hatred among politicians, clergymen and even the educated elite, who abandoned their societal role.”

Nahidh al-Ramadhani, a Mosul author and playwright whose novel “The Hope Vendor” chronicled the first days of IS, says the reason no one has been accountable so far comes down to corruption.

“The political class in Iraq avoids opening corruption files because many of them are involved,” said Ramadhani, “If we held them accountable, the political process would collapse. The same applies to the fall of Mosul; it will harm the political process as many of them are involved. It is a strange, unacceptable claim, but everything is possible in Iraq. Any crime can pass to secure the continuity of the political process, which is considered as an ends and a means to itself.”

For Ramadhani and others, Sairoon’s statements every now and then have goal of scoring political points against rivals.

“With this oligarchy, we will never see any transparent, credible investigation,” he said.

In June 2018, a report on the fall of Mosul cast blame on the Mosul commander, Lt. Gen. Mahdi al-Gharrawi, who, among others, withdrew from Mosul. The report also drew an image of pre-takeover Mosul when royalties of about $5 million per month were imposed by IS on Mosul residents, and 40% of regional development funds went to IS. The report spoke of the failure of the government to protect Christians, Yazidis and Shabaks from IS atrocities, forcing many to leave the city. The report said corruption also led to allowing many IS members to be set free in exchange for bribes, including Mosul’s first IS wali, or custodian. In addition, the report said that many soldiers before the fall used to pay half of their salaries to their leaders in exchange for taking leaves. That left one brigade with 76 soldiers instead of 500 before the IS invasion. 

“A number of officials have been named in the report,” said Ezzo, “It seems that the sectarian/ethnic balance played a role even in balancing of the number of the accused from all societal parties.”

Edward said, “Nobody will be punished, for the people of Mosul and Sinjar are still displaced,” referring to the displaced people camps she works in, “If there was a real punishment, we would have seen the punishment of some IS members who are still in the camps. Some were forced to join, but some voluntarily joined the terrorist group.”

While investigations are an important and popular demand, reconstruction seems to be a priority for many living in Mosul.

“All reconstruction efforts are personal ones; the government is not doing anything,” said Harith al-Abbasi, an Arabic teacher and blogger from Mosul, “Some feel the government is not willing to reconstruct and revive Mosul. The Infrastructure is in bad condition, only one out of five bridges has been restored. Compensation for those who had lost their properties is a priority. There are volunteer and international reconstruction efforts, but where is the government? We cannot pave the streets or establish new schools ourselves.”

Reconnecting Mosul’s eastern and western parts, restoring hospitals and compensating the affected people will revitalize the city’s economic life, Ezzo said.

Saman Dawed, a Germany-based Yazidi journalist and activist, said, “There is an urgent need to reveal the fate of the Yazidi and Turkmen abductees and form a team to search for them and find realistic solutions to the political disputes in Ninevah.” 

Still, people do not trust the current government’s ability to achieve so.

Continue reading this article by registering at no cost and get unlimited access to:
  • Al-Monitor Archives
  • The Week in Review
  • Exclusive Events
  • Invitation-only Briefings

Recommended Articles

Congress wants to see the Pentagon’s hidden costs of deterring Iran
Jared Szuba | Iran-US tensions | Aug 3, 2020
Six years after Yazidi massacre, US urged to take 'bolder action'
Elizabeth Hagedorn | Yazidis | Aug 3, 2020
Iraq’s prime minister says early elections to be held in June 2021
Al-Monitor Staff | Iraqi elections | Jul 31, 2020
Iraqi lawmaker calls for arming tribes amid attacks on Sunni communities
Shelly Kittleson | | Jul 31, 2020
Yazidi activist Nadia Murad to appear on 'The Daily Show'
Al-Monitor Staff | Women’s rights | Jul 30, 2020

More from  Iraq

al-monitor
After 30-year hiatus, French archaeological mission returns to Iraq
Adnan Abu Zeed | Cultural heritage | Aug 8, 2020
al-monitor
No quick fix for Iraq's electricity crisis
Omar Sattar | | Aug 7, 2020
al-monitor
Has Iraq failed to control drone movement?
Mustafa Saadoun | | Aug 7, 2020
al-monitor
Pro-Iran militias continue hitting military bases in Iraq
Shelly Kittleson | Armed Militias and Extremist Groups | Aug 5, 2020