Egypt takes action to investigate notorious prison

The Egyptian government has promised to investigate the conditions at the Tora Maximum Security Prison following complaints by prisoners’ families and nongovernmental organizations.

al-monitor Policemen and other people walk in front of the main gate of Tora prison on the outskirts of Cairo, Egypt, June 4, 2012.  Photo by REUTERS/Amr Abdallah Dalsh.
Menna A. Farouk

Menna A. Farouk

@MennaFarouk91

Topics covered

Human rights

Nov 6, 2017

Egypt is taking action to assess the situation in Cairo’s notorious Tora Maximum Security Prison, also known as Al-Aqrab (Scorpion) prison, and determine its suitability to host inmates.

The decision came after complaints filed by prisoners’ families and nongovernmental organizations called on the government to shut down the prison. The State Commissioners’ Committee, which is part of the country’s administrative courts, approved the complaints and assigned Cairo University to set up a tripartite committee comprising specialized experts in the fields of medicine, engineering and human rights in order to prepare a report about the prison.

The report, the committee said, should include the capability of the prison’s buildings and its annexes, especially the hospital, to receive inmates and whether the prison provides suitable living conditions, including clean water, healthy food and proper health care, for prisoners.

Human rights activists have praised the committee’s decision, saying that it gives hope to the prison’s inmates and highlights the state’s willingness to improve its human rights record.

George Ishaq, an activist and a member of the state-run National Council for Human Rights, said that the decision by the State Commissioners’ Committee is a move in the right direction. “It is a decision that should have been taken a long time ago,” Ishaq told Al-Monitor.

Ishaq noted that in a previous visit to the Tora prison he had observed inappropriate living conditions inside the prison. He highlighted the lack of beds and poor health-care services. “The prison is not a place for humans,” the veteran politician said. “That's why it is sound to take such a decision,” he added.

Egypt has recently been criticized for human rights violations. In September, Human Rights Watch released a report, accusing the Egyptian authorities of systematic torture in prisons.

In a statement, the Egyptian Foreign Ministry lashed out at the Human Rights Watch report, saying that it harmed the reputation of the country and ignored the recent progress made by the government in the field of human rights.

“It is lamentable that an organization claiming to be defending freedoms and human rights in the world adopts an approach that contradicts with such values. The report has lent a deaf ear to all aspects of progress that were achieved in the field of human rights in Egypt in recent years,” Foreign Ministry spokesman Ahmed Abu Zeid said in a statement.

In a September meeting with Mohamed Fayek, the head of the National Council for Human Rights, Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi asserted the state’s determination to pursue its efforts for fostering human rights and guaranteeing principal freedoms. This, the president said, comes in line with efforts to combat terrorism and extremism as well as protect the national security from various risks that Egypt and the region are subject to at present.

Fayek presented to Sisi a report that called for improving living conditions for prisoners, upgrading the level of detention centers and paying due attention to the role played by the civil society. The report also included recommendations that go in line with Egypt’s international commitments regarding human rights as well as with the provisions of the Egyptian Constitution. The recommendations included the organization of events aimed at spreading the culture of human rights in addition to continuing the improvement of economic and social conditions for citizens.

The Egyptian parliament also debated this year the introduction of a subject on human rights in the Egyptian curriculum in order to eliminate extremist ideology and raise awareness among young people about their political rights and their national duties.

Margaret Azer, a member of the parliamentary Human Rights Committee, said that international gatherings usually use human rights to pressure certain policies in Egypt.

“It is always used against Egypt because there is a lack of a good mechanism that can address the West or the media and is capable of clarifying the true picture of what is happening in Egypt abroad,” Azer told local media. The parliamentarian suggested the launch of a specialized channel that can clarify the visions of the Egyptian state and all sticking points to the West.

Continue reading this article by registering at no cost and get unlimited access to:
  • Al-Monitor Archives
  • The Week in Review
  • Exclusive Events
  • Invitation-only Briefings

Recommended Articles

The lesser of two evils: Yemen’s Bahais from prison into exile
A correspondent in Yemen | Ethnic/Religious Minorities | Aug 10, 2020
Journalists in Yemen attacked ‘from all quarters,’ UN rights chief says
Al-Monitor Staff | Press freedom | Aug 6, 2020
State Department remains concerned by Turkey’s proxy fighters in northern Syria
Elizabeth Hagedorn | Turkish-Kurdish conflict | Aug 5, 2020
The Takeaway: Will catastrophe reshape Lebanon’s social contract?
Andrew Parasiliti | Israeli elections | Aug 5, 2020
Appointing military advisers to oversee civil life in Egypt stirs anger
A correspondent in Egypt | | Aug 9, 2020

More from  Egypt

al-monitor
Al-Madaq: A new virtual archive documenting Cairo’s history
A correspondent in Egypt | Architecture | Aug 10, 2020
al-monitor
Appointing military advisers to oversee civil life in Egypt stirs anger
A correspondent in Egypt | | Aug 9, 2020
al-monitor
Egypt helps unify Yemen rivals behind Riyadh deal
Mohamed Sabry | Yemen war | Aug 5, 2020
al-monitor
Cairo denounces Hagia Sophia move, develops Egypt's Christian sites
George Mikhail | | Aug 7, 2020