Iraqi Kurds fear fallout from Erdogan-Gulen conflict

Some Iraqi Kurds are worried that the potential fall of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan might result in a reversal of good relations between Erbil and Ankara.

al-monitor Turkey's Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan and President of Iraqi Kurdistan Massoud Barzani (R) attend a ceremony with Erdogan's wife, Emine Erdogan, in Diyarbakir, Nov. 16, 2013. Photo by REUTERS.

Topics covered

turkey, politics, pipeline, oil, kurdistan regional government, kurdish peace process, iraqi kurdistan, iraq

Mar 17, 2014

ERBIL, Iraq — The Kurdistan Regional Government of Iraq (KRG) has had a blossoming political and economic relationship with Turkey since 2009. After the Arab Spring, KRG President Massoud Barzani became one of the few friends Turkey has left in the region. With rising internal problems in Turkey amid upcoming elections, Iraqi Kurds wonder about the future of Turkey’s Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

The open war between former allies — Erdogan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) and the Fethullah Gulen community — is also affecting the Kurdistan region. The Gulen community operates 18 schools in Iraqi Kurdistan with approximately 5,000 students, many coming from the Kurdish elites.

Pro-AKP media accused the Gulen movement of running spying centers in Iraqi Kurdistan that tapped the phones of pro-AKP Turkish businessmen who insulted Kurds while signing business deals with the KRG for $1 billion, according to Peace and Democracy Party (BDP) MP Altan Tan in the Turkish parliament. “And Massoud Barzani, if you let these two ignoble people to win those contracts, shame on Kurdistan and shame on you!” he said.

The KRG quickly denied the existence of Gulen spying cells in Kurdistan and denied reports by Gulen media that Erdogan asked KRG Prime Minister Nechirvan Barzani to close their schools. “We haven’t received such a request,” said Falah Mustafa Bakir, KRG’s foreign minister, to Al-Monitor.

Relations between the Erdogan government and the KRG have improved dramatically in recent years. “In the past, our relationship with Turkey was not official. Before it was with the [Turkish] intelligence service or the military. But now it’s officially on a political and an economic level,” Jafaar Eminki, spokesman for Barzani’s Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP), told Al-Monitor.

In 2009, Turkey’s Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu paid the first official visit to Erbil, with the Turks opening a consulate in the city. Now, almost half of registered foreign companies in Iraqi Kurdistan are from Turkey.

Energy-poor Turkey wants to benefit from Iraqi Kurdistan’s proximity to Turkish borders and make itself less dependent on Iranian and Russian gas in the future. The KRG began piping oil to Turkey without the approval of Baghdad this year. But so far, the 1 million barrels of crude being held in tanks in the oil hub of Ceyhan have yet to be sold. “We are waiting for an agreement with Baghdad,” Bakir said.

According to the International Crisis Group, Barzani’s party hopes that Turkey’s thirst for oil and gas will align with their own thirst for Kurdish statehood. The KDP wants to make the Kurdish region economically independent from Baghdad. But not all Kurdish parties in Iraq support this, in particular those with close ties to Iran.

“The relationship between neighboring countries has not been organized through institutions, it’s a partisan relationship between the KDP and Turkey,” said Amanj Abdullah, a member of the Kurdish opposition party, Change, in Erbil to Al-Monitor.

Also, members of Jalal Talabani’s Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) see the relationship as too dependent on Turkey, and want a better dialogue with Baghdad. “We have to be careful not to be misled by Turkey, which might eventually come to terms with Baghdad and make us lose what we already have,” Adil Murad, co-founder of the PUK, told the Sulaimaniyah News Network.

The KDP’s spokesman Jafaar Eminki disputed that it only has ties to the AKP, insisting it works with all Turkish parties. “We have relations with all Turkish parties, apart from those who are nationalist and who follow race as a basis for their negotiations.”

Both Iraqi and Turkish Kurdish parties do not enjoy good ties with the AKP’s rivals. The secular Republican People’s Party (CHP) has warmed up to the Gulen movement, which opposes the peace process. The ultranationalist Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) is vehemently opposed to any form of Kurdish autonomy in the region. Both the MHP and the CHP have been critical of Turkey’s ties to the KRG at the expense of greater ties with Baghdad.

The PKK is not a fan of the Turkish ruling party, but also sees no alternative to it. Acting PKK leader Cemil Bayik told the Turkish newspaper Vatan that the CHP can only come to power if it takes radical steps in the Kurdish problem and Turkey’s democratization. “In its present state, it is far from coming to power or solving the power problem. Can the MHP solve the power problem? It is clearly far from that.”

But former Turkish ambassador to Iraq, Murat Ozcelik, said that although certain parties criticize KRG-Turkey relations, this would not change Turkey’s foreign policy toward the KRG even if the government changed.

“This policy of Turkey enhancing its relations with the KRG will not change. It’s irreversible. And mind you, don’t get discouraged by the coming debates in Turkey. We are now in an election period,” he said in a conference in Sulaimaniyah on March 5, attended by Al-Monitor’s Turkey Pulse.

The KDP is still confident the AKP will win the elections despite corruption allegations against the ruling party. Some observers in Erbil believe the graft probe hasn’t had a major impact on public support for the AKP.

“According to some friends and new polls, the AKP is not going to lose,” Hemin Hawrami, the head of the KDP’s foreign relations, told Al-Monitor.

On March 15, Davutoglu and Nechirvan Barzani announced plans to build a new bridge between Turkey and the KRG and open five more border gates, further testimony to the growing relationship.

“We hope we will have the same relationship with whatever party comes to power,” Eminki said. 

Recommended Articles

Libya says oil blockade has cost $5 billion in lost revenue
Al-Monitor Staff | Libya conflict | May 28, 2020
Two men arrested in US for allegedly helping Carlos Ghosn flee Japan
Al-Monitor Staff | Courts and the law | May 20, 2020
Islamic State believed behind crop fires in Iraq's disputed territories
Al-Monitor Staff | Islamic State | May 13, 2020
Intel: Iraq’s Peshmerga Ministry pushes for joint security talks with Baghdad
Jared Szuba | Defense/Security cooperation | May 12, 2020
Turkey charges 7 over ex-Nissan boss’s escape to Lebanon
Al-Monitor Staff | Courts and the law | May 8, 2020

More from  Iraq

Iraqi forces team up for anti-IS operation in Kirkuk
Shelly Kittleson | Islamic State | Jun 4, 2020
Anti-Saudi blocs in Iraqi parliament want to sue
Omar Sattar | Courts and the law | Jun 3, 2020
Pro-Iran militias in Iraq wage 'fake news' campaign against US
Hamdi Malik | | Jun 2, 2020
Rainbow flags over Baghdad fan debate, spur fear
Gilgamesh Nabeel | | May 28, 2020