Skip to main content

Slotkin, Van Hollen emerge as potential challengers to Schumer’s Senate leadership

A growing number of Democrats are calling for new leadership in the Senate to replace Schumer, arguing that the party needs a leader who better reflects its generational and ideological shift to the left.

WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 23: U.S. Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI) speaks at a press conference on China AI export controls at the U.S. Capitol on September 23, 2026 in Washington, DC. Slotkin, joined by fellow Senate Democrats, urged Senate Republican's and the Trump administration to enact stronger export controls on AI technology and computer chips to China. The Democrats also call for a vote on bipartisan export control legislation, including the AI OVERWATCH Act, the MATCH Act, and the Chip Security Act. (
US Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-Mich.) speaks at a press conference on China AI export controls at the US Capitol on Sept. 23, 2026, in Washington. — Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images

NEW YORK/WASHINGTON — Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) is facing the prospect of leadership challenges within his own party, with Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) and Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-Mich.) weighing potential bids for the party’s top spot in the Senate.

Chris Van Hollen

Van Hollen, a progressive Democrat who has criticized Schumer’s leadership, has received a growing number of calls encouraging him to challenge the New York senator and is now actively considering the possibility, Punchbowl News reported Monday, citing a person familiar with his thinking.

Speaking on Saturday at a Crooked Media event, Van Hollen said, “We need to have a discussion in the Democratic caucus.” He added, “Nobody should get a blank check without a full understanding from the caucus as to where we’re going to go.”

Newly elected Sen. Abdul El-Sayed (D-Mich.) told CNN on Thursday that he backs Van Hollen for the leadership position, saying, “I think he’d be amazing at the job.”

The 67-year-old Maryland senator has emerged as one of the Senate’s most vocal critics of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government and US military assistance to Israel. He has voted to block US weapons transfers to Israel, including backing two resolutions in April seeking to halt the sale of 1,000-pound bombs and military bulldozers to Israel, both of which failed in the Senate.

In September, Van Hollen helped introduce a resolution requiring the State Department to report to Congress on Israeli settler violence in the occupied West Bank. The Senate blocked the measure.

In July, he told Maryland Matters that he has “always been for a two-state solution … because it is the one approach that allows for self-determination for the people of Israel and self-determination for the Palestinians.” He added, “We cannot have a blank check for Netanyahu.”

He has taken a similarly critical position on the ongoing conflict with Iran, repeatedly pushing war powers resolutions aimed at forcing a Senate vote to end US military involvement in the conflict. In April, he introduced a war powers resolution alongside several Democratic colleagues. Following its introduction, Van Hollen said, “Trump promised to keep America out of foreign wars and work to bring prices down, but he has done just the opposite by launching an illegal war of choice with Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu in Iran.” He referred to the war as “reckless.”

Elissa Slotkin

Meanwhile, asked about a potential bid at the Crooked Media event on Saturday, Slotkin said, “I’m not ruling anything out.” She later told Politico that she would not vote for Schumer “if we don’t have a plan” for the first 100 days of the next Congress, which begins in January. She called for a “new generation” of leaders.

Slotkin, 50, has expressed measured concerns about US support for Israel compared with progressives in the party. In July 2025, she said in a statement that she would consider votes on limiting offensive weapons to Israel on a “case-by-case basis,” citing humanitarian concerns in Gaza.

Slotkin cosigned a letter in January 2024 declaring that South Africa’s genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice was “grossly unfounded.”

She entered the Senate in 2025, having previously served in the House. She worked as an analyst for the CIA before entering politics. Slotkin reportedly speaks Arabic and was stationed in Iraq while working for the intelligence agency.

In January 2020, Slotkin sponsored a resolution aimed at limiting Trump’s ability to conduct strikes on Iran after the US strike that killed Iranian commander Qassem Soleimani in Baghdad that month.

A year earlier, she was one of only a handful of Democrats to vote against a ban on US military assistance to Saudi Arabia in the Yemen war. Saudi Arabia supports the Yemeni government in the war against the Iran-backed Houthi rebels, and the kingdom’s strikes on Yemen were widely criticized at the time for resulting in civilian casualties.

Other contenders

Other potential contenders include Sens. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii) and Cory Booker (D-N.J.), all of whom have been mentioned as possible alternatives to Schumer.

Murphy, 53, suffered a stroke on Oct. 31. He announced Friday that he had been released from the hospital.

Schumer has signaled his intention to keep his position, telling reporters last week, “I’ll be reelected as majority leader.” The top Democrat in the chamber since 2017 has supported US military aid to Israel but voiced criticism of Netanyahu, calling the premier an “obstacle to peace” in a 2024 speech. Schumer said last week that the next Congress would use its spending oversight to end the Iran war.

Senate Democrats are expected to choose their leadership in closed-door elections in early December. Under caucus rules, if no candidate wins a majority in the first round of voting, senators hold additional rounds, with the lowest-performing candidate eliminated each time until someone secures a majority. Newly elected senators will participate in the voting.

The incoming Congress is expected to challenge Trump’s foreign policy agenda by reconsidering aid to Israel, limiting Iran war funding, and investigating business ties between the Trump family and the Gulf. El-Sayed in particular is representative of a growing number of Democrats in Congress who want to cut military aid to Israel. Last April, 40 of the 47 members of the Democratic caucus voted to block a weapons sale to Israel.

An AL-MONITOR subscriber gifted you this article. Gifted by an AL-MONITOR subscriber.

A gift worth sharing.

This one's on us. Subscribe for unlimited access to everything we publish, plus gift articles for your inner circle. As low as $2/week. This one's on us. Get unlimited access, plus gift articles for your inner circle, from $2 a week.

Related Topics