Will court's decision to dismiss Israeli arson confession set precedent?

An Israeli court has ruled that the Shin Bet's interrogation methods used on Jews suspected of terror attacks against Palestinians were unacceptable, freeing a confessed arsonist implicated in the murder of the Dawabsha family.

al-monitor Palestinian boy Ahmed Dawabsha, who suffered severe burns in an arson attack on his family home last year in which his younger brother and his parents both died, is carried by his grandfather during an event marking the first anniversary of the incident in the West Bank village of Douma near Nablus, West Bank, July 31, 2016. Photo by REUTERS/Abed Omar Qusini.
Shlomi Eldar

Shlomi Eldar

@shlomieldar

Topics covered

torture, israeli courts, shin bet, israeli-palestinian conflict, jewish terrorism, dawabsha, douma

Jul 13, 2018

A Jewish Israeli charged with the 2015 murder of a Palestinian family was freed July 12 and remanded to house arrest under electronic monitoring. The accused, identified only by the initial A., was detained two and a half years ago and charged with involvement in torching the home of the Dawabsha family in the West Bank village of Douma in July 2015, killing Sa’ad and Riham and their 18-month-old son Ali and severely injuring 4-year-old Ahmed. The case set off a storm, with many Israelis refusing to believe that Jews were responsible for such a horrific attack. The Shin Bet arrested several suspects four months later, treating them as terrorists and using interrogation methods accordingly. It initially denied them access to lawyers, as the Shin Bet often does with Palestinian detainees, in an effort to uncover the Jewish terror cell operating in the West Bank and threatening to ignite an intifada.

The suspects claimed interrogators had roughed them up and subjected them to other physical abuse, exactly as the Shin Bet does when interrogating Palestinian suspects considered “ticking time bombs.” This term is used in cases when a detainee is suspected of holding information that could reveal plans for imminent terror attacks. Under interrogation at a Shin Bet facility, a right-wing activist named Amiram Ben-Uliel confessed to throwing firebombs at the Dawabsha family home. The other suspect, whose name is being withheld as he was a minor at the time, admitted to being involved in planning the attack with Ben-Uliel. In 2016, serious charges were brought against them.

After being allowed to meet with lawyers hired for them by the right-wing legal aid organization Honenu, the suspects claimed their confessions were extracted by force and they had admitted to an act that they had not committed. On June 20, the Lod District Court ruled invalid the confessions obtained by so-called “special means.” “These means severely violated the accused’s basic right to the integrity of body and soul. It also hurt the accused’s dignity,” the three judges ruled. Other confessions made by the accused when not under torture were deemed admissible.

“Obviously the Shin Bet caused physical pain and suffering to the suspect under interrogation to get him to confess,” said Yitzhak Bam, Ben-Uliel’s lawyer, after the court’s ruling. “A legal system that respects human dignity cannot accept as evidence confessions extracted under physical suffering.”

After the July 12 decision to release A. to house arrest, his father said, “The court’s decision validates what we claimed throughout: Our son underwent severe torture under interrogation.”

The ruling surprised the Shin Bet. In a statement, the organization said Shin Bet interrogations are an important and central element in thwarting terrorism of any kind and solving cases of terror attacks. Information obtained during investigations saves many human lives and makes a huge contribution to the security of the state.

Nonetheless, unlike the praise usually enjoyed by the Shin Bet for using “special means” against those considered “ticking time bombs” and thus foiling terror attacks, this time the agency came under fire by the court. Is a basic right to the integrity of body and soul reserved only for Jewish suspects?

Continue reading this article by registering at no cost and get unlimited access to:
  • Al-Monitor Archives
  • The Week in Review
  • Exclusive Events
  • Invitation-only Briefings

Recommended Articles

House Democrats revive bid to fully restore Palestinian aid
Bryant Harris | Israeli-Palestinian conflict | Jul 7, 2020
Has Israel lost control over coronavirus pandemic?
Rina Bassist | Coronavirus | Jul 6, 2020
Palestinian Authority to pay civil servants half their monthly wages amid cash crunch
Al-Monitor Staff | Israeli-Palestinian conflict | Jul 2, 2020
Complaints of torture on rise in Turkey's Kurdish southeast
Pinar Tremblay | Kurds | Jul 8, 2020
Vatican summons Israel, US ambassadors over West Bank annexation
Al-Monitor Staff | Israeli-Palestinian conflict | Jul 2, 2020

More from  Israel

al-monitor
Israeli army hit hard by coronavirus
Rina Bassist | | Jul 9, 2020
al-monitor
Israel’s middle class sags as aid package delayed
Mazal Mualem | | Jul 9, 2020
al-monitor
Israel, UAE test potential for cooperation on COVID-19
Danny Zaken | Coronavirus | Jul 9, 2020
al-monitor
Palestinian workers stay in Israel for three weeks in a row
Rina Bassist | Coronavirus | Jul 9, 2020