Erdogan's interest rate agenda
Author: Kadri Gursel Posted June 4, 2014
After the March 30 local elections, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan began applying suffocating pressure on Erdem Basci, the governor of Turkey’s Central Bank, to lower the interest rates he deemed as too high.
The frequent calls to “lower the interest rate” by Erdogan in his usual abrasive manner, in a language tantamount to scolding, are threatening the presumed independence of the Central Bank and denting the international prestige of the institution.
Of course, a higher cost will be the fortified impression that Turkey is on the verge of becoming a “command economy” amid the heavy pressure the Central Bank is under.
It is not a coincidence this offensive against the Central Bank was begun immediately after the March 30 local elections.
High tension between Erdogan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) and the Gulen movement had turned to an all-out war as a result of the anti-graft operations of Dec. 17 and Dec. 25. The ensuing crisis caused sharp increases in the dollar-euro parity. The Central Bank decided to increase on Jan. 29 its weekly repo rates by 5.5 points to 10% to balance this parity.
Erdogan lost fewer votes than expected in the local elections, despite his family and his party facing serious corruption accusations. In addition, the two crucially important urban centers of Ankara and Istanbul retained their AKP mayors.
The prime minister must have believed the political conjuncture that had led to the interest rate increase was no longer valid after the March 30 elections, and that it was time to lower the interest rate, when five days after the elections he declared that the markets were responding positively to the election results. Erdogan said, “The Central Bank, similarly to when it met in an extraordinary session to increase the interest rate, must now lower it. When the interest rate goes down, investors will be encouraged. They will invest more. It will be easier to use credits."
Erdogan has justified reasons for wanting to lower the interest rate. The AKP government has been put under pressure by a falling growth rate. Turkey, whose economy grew by 8.5% in 2011, registered a growth rate of 2.2% in 2012 and 4% in 2013. For 2014-15, a growth rate of 3.5-4% is forecast.
Unless a major surprise occurs, Erdogan will run in the August presidential elections as the AKP candidate. In 2015, the general elections will take place, and a persistent low growth rate could well lead to the loss of votes for the government.
We must also note that the construction sector is most affected by interest rate hikes, which includes capital groups that substantially support the government.
The Central Bank's Monetary Market Council did not meet Erdogan’s expectations of a sharp reduction in interest rates at its meeting on May 22, and lowered the weekly repo interest rate only by half a point from 10% to 9.5%.
Erdogan’s reaction to Basci was harsh. In his address to the AKP parliamentary group on May 27, he said, "So what? What independence? … Don’t make fun of people [by lowering the interest rate by] half a point. This interest rate is too high. This has to go down so that real investments will increase. We are politicians. We are accountable to people.”
He continued, “It's enough. I have to say this. … The interest rate is the cause, inflation is the effect.”
According to Erdogan’s thesis, which points to inflation as an effect of interest, if the interest rate is lowered, inflation will follow.
The Turkish Statistical Agency revised its annual inflation rate at 9.38% for April. Inflation is on the rise. With his interest rate-inflation theory, Erdogan can easily point to Basci as the culprit of climbing inflation, because he did not sufficiently lower the interest rate.
Erdogan’s theory has led to a media debate. Economists and economy writers said Erdogan’s thinking was erroneous, and that exactly the opposite is true: Inflation is the cause, and the interest rate is the effect.
Erdogan’s interest rate-inflation theory is not new. For instance, 2½ years ago when observing the Working Journalists' Day of Prime Ministry reporters, he had said, "Now I'm giving my opinion. Inflation will be high if the market interest rate is high. I don’t really take others into account. But inflation will be low if we can pull down the market interest rate. If we had been able to lower inflation — which was around 30% when we took control — to 5%, we did that by lowering the interest rate."
Erdogan's astounding views on interest rates emanate from his peculiar populism, which Islamism blended with populism. Although he is a religious person, Erdogan knows well that because of country and global realities he cannot categorically ban interest payments. But knowing that he has to soothe the sentiments of his religious base, he focuses on the interest rate in his reactions; for instance, with the concept of the “interest rate lobby.”
The world met with the “interest rate lobby” when Erdogan declared that the Gezi Park protests were a plot by the “interest rate lobby” that sought to weaken and destabilize Turkey. In fact, the “interest rate lobby" was a concept Erdogan had been using for quite some time. In the same 2012 speech, he had said, “They will take firm action against the interest rate lobby and won’t let it operate freely.”
When Erdogan’s image in the world changed negatively because of his irrational and harsh reaction to the Gezi Park movement, the positive global perceptions about him over the first years of his rule were also shattered. The world is watching Erdogan much more closely. Highly problematic, confounding concepts such as the “interest rate lobby,” which did not really distract from positive perceptions at the beginning and were not generally questioned, are now inflicting serious damage to Erdogan’s image.
The late Necmettin Erbakan, the founder and historical leader of the Islamist National View movement that also gave birth to Erdogan’s rise to prominence, was also a strong anti-interest rate politician. In Erbakan’s narrative, “pro-interest rate capitalism under the control of Zionists was exploiting humanity and Turkey."
Erdogan does not speak like his master Erbakan. Erdogan has startling targets such as the "zero interest rate” that cannot be explained with the operational logic of the banking system.
In a meeting with businessmen on April 29, 2011, he said he sees interest rates as oppression. “We are not the oppressor. We are a government confronting oppression,” he said, adding that their target was to reduce the interest rate to zero.
“What is the target? The target, God willing, is to bring down the interest rate and inflation to the same level. We will do it. To achieve a zero interest, we must do it," he said.
His words had attracted attention in earlier years — for instance, at the 2006 D-8 Summit in Bali of eight Muslim countries: "We should not limit ourselves to the issue of Islamic interest. We have to play according to international rules. Let’s look at the characteristics of interest rates.”
In the reactions that followed, the sentiment was that Erdogan had meant to say that what is haram is not the interest rate at the same level as the inflation rate, but an interest rate above the rate of inflation.
In sum, it is not only the election calculations behind Erdogan’s “lower interest rate” pressure on the Central Bank, but also his ideology and a “moderate anti-interest rate stand” based on this worldview.
Read More: http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2014/06/turkey-erdogan-interest-rate-central-bank-erdem-basci.html
Kadri Gursel is a columnist for Al-Monitor's Turkey Pulse and Turkish daily Cumhuriyet. His main focuses are Turkish foreign policy, international affairs, press freedom, Turkey’s Kurdish question, as well as Turkey’s evolving political Islam and its national and regional impacts. He wrote a column for the Turkish daily Milliyet between 2007 and July 2015. Gursel also worked for the Agence France-Presse for nearly five years, between 1993-1997 as an İstanbul based correspondent. While at the AFP, he was kidnapped by Kurdish militants in 1995. He recounted his misadventures at the hands of the PKK in his book titled “Dağdakiler” (Those of the Mountains) published in 1996. Twitter: @KadriGursel