Skip to main content

Is There Really a Turkish 'Jihad' Against Alcohol?

No, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan is not waging a jihad on alcohol in Turkey. A response to Kadri Gursel.

TO GO WITH AFP STORY BURAK AKINCI 
This photo taken on January 29, 2011, in Ankara, shows protesters drinking alcohol as they demonstrate against new laws banning alcohol sales in the Turkish capital and several Anatolian towns. Since 2002 the conservative ruling Justice and Development Party has brought many new bureaucratic hurdles to the sale of alcohol nationwide. Most recently, authorities in the province of Afyon tried to forbid alcohol completely but had to exlude "picnic" zones from the restriction
This photo taken on Jan. 29, 2011, in Ankara, shows protesters drinking alcohol as they demonstrate against new laws banning alcohol sales in the Turkish capital and several Anatolian towns. — ADEM ALTAN/AFP/GettyImages

On May 23, fellow Al-Monitor writer Kadri Gursel had a nice piece crowned by a provocative headline: “AKP Wages Jihad Against Alcohol in Turkey.” The rest of the piece did not mention the j-word again, nor did it explain how it exactly fit the issue, but the title was enough to give an impression that Turkey's ruling party was leading an explicitly Islamic campaign against alcohol.

However, none other than the AKP leadership itself has explicitly denied that this was the case. Bulent Arinc, vice prime minister and second after Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan within the AKP hierarchy, spoke to the press about the new alcohol regulations of his government, emphasizing:

“About alcohol, religious considerations should be set aside. That is a separate matter. Everybody's outlook on alcohol based on his beliefs are certain. I only respect that in my private life, and I exercise mine. But asserting this concern for everybody, turning this into a law, is not possible in a secular state. What we do is implement the constitutional clause about the protection of the youth and the family.”

In other words, Arinc emphasized that the AKP's alcohol regulations were based not on religious beliefs but on objective concerns about public health, safety and order. Several days later, Erdogan, in a heated if not crude tone, also argued that the fact that religion (in this case, Islam) also condemns alcohol should not be a reason to oppose the regulations on alcohol.

SUBSCRIBER EXCLUSIVE

Continue reading this exclusive analysis

Original reporting and analysis unavailable elsewhere. Subscribe to AL-MONITOR to read this story and access everything we publish